Written and clinically reviewed by Pace Lawson, LPC, LCDC.
challenging defenses
One of the therapist’s key functions is to understand the patient’s patterns of feeling, thinking, and relating. Some patients begin with symptoms—“knots” in their stomach, depressive rumination, nightmares. Others begin with what has happened between them and other people. Neither starting point tells us, by itself, whether a personality disorder is present. The therapist needs a fuller history, an understanding of current circumstances, and attention to the person’s functioning over time. A personality-disorder assessment goes well beyond a single complaint or conversation.
Cain presents with “knots” in his stomach. That gives us a starting point, not a conclusion about his personality. When he begins condemning others in session, the therapist becomes curious about the experiences behind it. Cain reports, “I hate people and often fantasize about leaving everyone to live alone in the forest.”
The therapist initially seeks to normalize the statement, “Sages, wisdom-seekers, and monks across the span of centuries have done exactly that,” to give Cain the benefit of the doubt, he may be experiencing a natural phenomenon of the spirit.
On the other hand, what does he mean when he says, “I hate people,” and what does he hope “living alone in the forest” would change? Solitude can offer reflection, relief, or escape; the therapist cannot know which meaning fits Cain without asking. The initial response is to make room for his experience, then consider possible explanations quietly. Patient and therapist are still in the evaluation stage, and any firm interpretation of his personality would be premature.
A note is made that Cain may be pulling away from connection. To understand the pattern more fully, the therapist asks, “What do you hate about people?”
“They’ve all betrayed me. I don’t trust anyone.”
Cain feels betrayed, and that experience deserves to be taken seriously. Trauma-related symptoms, depression, ongoing relationship harm, and longstanding interpersonal patterns are among the possibilities to explore. PTSD and personality disorders may sometimes coexist, but these few statements establish neither diagnosis and do not limit the assessment to those two options. The therapist continues listening, gathering history, considering safety and current needs, and checking hypotheses with Cain rather than fitting him into a category too soon.
The conversation continues, “Can you tell me about the betrayal?”
References and further reading
- National Institute of Mental Health. Borderline personality disorder. Assessment includes symptoms and personal and family history.
- National Institute of Mental Health. Psychotherapies.
Editorial update, November 15, 2026: Broadened the diagnostic framing while retaining Cain’s dialogue and the focus on careful evaluation.